5. It is stated that the chemical potential of a phonon gas is zero, and that hence it is possible to obtain the average number of phonons in a crystal with frequency ω by substituting µ = 0 into 〈N〉 = k 1 e β(ϵk−µ) − 1 Explain how it is possible that µ = 0, if the free energy of an Einstein solid or the Debye solid explicitly depends on N ?

5. It is stated that the chemical potential of a phonon gas is zero, and that hence it is possible to obtain the average number of phonons in a crystal with frequency ω by substituting µ = 0 into ⟨N⟩ = k 1 e β(ϵk−µ) − 1 Explain how it is possible that µ = 0, if the free energy of an Einstein solid or the Debye solid explicitly depends on N ?

Image text
  1. It is stated that the chemical potential of a phonon gas is zero, and that hence it is possible to obtain the average number of phonons in a crystal with frequency ω by substituting μ = 0 into
N = k 1 e β ( ϵ k μ ) 1
Explain how it is possible that μ = 0 , if the free energy of an Einstein solid or the Debye solid explicitly depends on N ?

Detailed Answer